Speech - Bill C-307 - Phthalate
Control Act - November 1, 2007
Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to address the House
today to speak on the third and final reading of Bill
C-307, the proposed phthalate control act.
When the government took a look at the original
bill, it was badly written and, quite frankly, was not a
good legislation. However, I am happy to see that the
government was able to significantly amend the bill into
a form we could support.
As my hon. colleagues have already advised the
House, our government supports Bill
C-307 in its amended state.
The amended bill would ensure that the substances
under consideration, known as BBP, DBP and DEHP, would
continue to be managed through the existing process for
dealing with substances that may pose a threat to the
environment and to human health.
At the second reading debate, the government
expressed concern that Bill
C-307, as originally drafted, would circumvent the
comprehensive scientific assessment of phthalates, by
imposing an immediate and outright ban on the use of BBP,
DBP and DEHP.
I am very pleased that the hon. member for
Skeena—Bulkley Valley has acknowledged the
government's concerns and agrees to respect the
scientific assessment process provided for under the
Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999, otherwise
known as CEPA.
As we have heard today, the federal Departments of
Environment and Health have already assessed the risks
associated with the three subjects named in Bill
C-307. Actions have been taken, where warranted.
Having said that, the government fully supports the
reassessment of BBP and DBP within the next two years,
provided that these assessments use the appropriate
process, the CEPA review mechanism. We are also prepared
to support additional regulatory measures to strengthen
control of DEHP, which has been proven to have
associated health risks.
Both of these measures are included in Bill
C-307 and are consistent with the government's
commitment to protect human health and the environment,
as reiterated in the recent Speech from the Throne. They
are also consistent with the government's chemical
management plan, which I will discuss in more detail
shortly.
I am pleased to confirm that Bill
C-307 no longer subverts CEPA, which provides the
framework for identifying, prioritizing and assessing
existing substances for controlling or managing those
considered to pose a risk to Canadians or the
environment.
One of the stated goals of CEPA is to manage risk
from substances. This recognizes the reality that, from
time to time, we will come across substances that may
pose a threat to the environment or to health but that
also offer important benefits.
DEHP is such a substance. There are health concerns
associated with human exposure, but a ban on DEHP could
create severe problems for the medical community as
there are currently no viable alternatives for this
plasticizer in certain medical devices.
CEPA's management process relies on scientific
evidence and comprehensive research and monitoring
programs. The science around phthalates is constantly
evolving, so we welcome the reassessments of BBP and DBP
called for in the bill, Bill
C-307, as they will help build our knowledge and
support sound decision-making.
One particularly important aspect of the CEPA
process is that the public and interested groups are
given adequate notice about risk assessments that are
planned or underway. They have also the opportunity to
comment on the results before decisions are made. This
public involvement element was lacking in Bill
C-307 as originally presented to this House.
CEPA also allows for some flexibility in terms of
risk management responses, taking into account not only
environmental and health issues, but also social,
economic and technological factors. Regulations are
sometimes the answer, but not always. For example, Bill
C-307 would provide for the development of clinical
practice guidelines for using medical devices that
contain DEHP.
The
government is committed to working with all our partners
to ensure that Canada is at the forefront of
international chemicals management and that our citizens
and our environment is protected.
Last December, we unveiled a chemicals management
plan. This plan provides for immediate action to
regulate chemicals that are harmful to human health or
the environment, and is a key element of our
government's comprehensive environmental and human
health agenda. We have committed $300 million over four
years to implement the chemicals management plan, which
will build on Canada's position as a global leader in
the safe management of chemical substances and products.
Taking action now will significantly reduce future
costs associated with water treatment, the clean up of
contaminated sites and treating illnesses related to
chemical exposure. It will improve the quality of life
of Canadians and better protect our environment. This
plan will also improve the conditions for business in
Canada by ensuring a level playing field and a
predictable, science based regulatory regime.
It provides for strengthened regulations and
enforcement, restrictions on reintroduction and new uses
of controlled substances, rapid screening of lower risk
chemical substances, accelerated re-evaluation of older
pesticides, mandatory ingredient labelling of cosmetics,
regulations to address environmental risks posed by
pharmaceuticals and personal care products, enhanced
management of environmental contaminants in food, health
monitoring, surveillance and research, increased risk
communications to the public and good stewardship of
chemical substances.
Under the umbrella of the chemicals management plan,
our government has developed a comprehensive strategy
for phthalates that includes many of the measures
provided for in Bill
C-307. An example of that is the phthalate strategy
includes reassessments of BBP and DBP under CEPA, the
implementation of controls to protect children under the
age of three and the development of clinical practice
guidelines for medical devices containing DEHP. It also
provides for the addition of DEHP to Health Canada's
cosmetic ingredient hot list, as well as the assessment
and risk management of other phthalates in cosmetics.
As part of the reassessment process, the government
will be reviewing the scientific evidence used to
support recent regulatory actions taken by the European
Union on DEHP, BBP and DBP, among other phthalates. Our
government will also continue to monitor the evolving
science on the use of DEHP in medical devices and will
take further actions, as required. I should point out
that none of Canada's major trading partners, including
the European Union, has prohibited DEHP in medical
devices such as blood bags and intravenous tubes.
Our government will continue to monitor 11 phthalate
metabolites and 8 parent phthalate compounds as part of
the Canadian health measures survey. In addition,
phthalates will be included in a proposed bio-monitoring
study for children from birth to six years of age. Data
from these studies will inform any future actions by the
government.
In short, our government is already taking
comprehensive action to assess and control phthalates
and other potentially harmful substances. Because
amended Bill
C-307 is consistent with these actions and with our
government's overall commitment to protecting Canadians
and their environment, we will vote in favour of this
legislation.